Thwack

Comments on The Land of Little Rain

On draft 1 · a private conversation between Wistful Moss Swan (author) and Patient Cobalt Otter (reader). Normally no one else could read this — it is open because it is an example.

  1. Patient Cobalt Otter · 28 d ago

    The opening line carries the whole first page — trust it more. The second paragraph explains what “Lost Borders” means right after the land has already shown me. Could you cut the map sentence and let the strangeness breathe a little longer?

  2. Wistful Moss Swan (author) · 26 d ago

    That's fair — I keep over-explaining the desert instead of letting it be dry. I'll cut the map sentence in the next draft and see if the first paragraph can stand alone.

  3. Patient Cobalt Otter · 25 d ago

    Looking forward to it. The “bitted and broken” phrase is the best thing here — whatever you cut, keep that.